GreenerWorking.com » Is it too easy to claim to be green? Congress wants to know

Is it too easy to claim to be green? Congress wants to know

June 9, 2009 by Tom Guay
Posted in: In this week's e-newsletter, Latest News & Views, News

It may get much harder to jump on the green bandwagon unless companies can prove how they measure the “greeniness” of their products and services.

Reason: Congress is gearing up to define what green means. A House Energy and Commerce panel meets today to put a stop to greenwashing — making false or unprovable claims about green attributes of products and services.

Rep. Bobby Rush (D-IL), chairman of the Commerce, Trade and Consumer Protection Subcommittee, is looking for legislative ways to define green marketing practices. Rush worries that consumers are being misled by a flurry of confusing green marketing claims.

He wants the Federal Trade Commission to impose standards that define what it takes to make an eco-friendly claim about a product, service or operation. Rush is responding to a greenwashing report that found that the number of products claiming to be green is increasing by 79% a year.

For hearing information and testimony, click here.

To eliminate greenwashing claims, the panel will focus on a study by the eco-marketing consultant firm, TerraChoice. The company’s report, the Seven Sins of Greenwashing, concludes that many green product claims misrepresent their supposedly environmentally friendly attributes. The report found that 98% of products reviewed committed at least one of the seven sins.

For example, TerraChoice says it’s misleading to claim that paper is green just because it was made from trees grown in a sustainable manner. The Seven Sins report notes that other more important factors are in play, including the type of energy used in the process, greenhouse gas emissions related to the making of the paper and the air and water pollution from pulp and paper mills.

Watch for legislation mandating third-party verification of green claims. Underwriters Laboratories has such a program.

  • Share/Bookmark

Tags: , , , , , , ,

4 Responses to “Is it too easy to claim to be green? Congress wants to know”

  1. tim Says:

    What happened to LEED and the US Green Building council? Or do I have too narrow of a focus?

  2. TERRY SHERWOOD Says:

    There will have to be a green rating system. I.E. 1-10 greening scale for instance. This will take out the confusion and cheating on truly green and not green at all.
    Thanks,
    Terry Sherwood

  3. Environmental News Bits»Blog Archive » Is it too easy to claim to be green? Congress wants to know Says:

    [...] Read the full post at GreenerWorking. It may get much harder to jump on the green bandwagon unless companies can prove how they measure the “greeniness” of their products and services. [...]

  4. Rachel White Says:

    I have to say that I’m skeptical of this effort. Congress is going to decide what green means? That strikes me as impossible and hopelessly flawed from the get go.

    Remember what happened with “organic”? Now that you have to be certified to use this term, small farms that were practicing organic methods long before it was fashionable are no longer allowed by law to call their practices what they are unless they get certified.

    Of course greenwashing is a big and growing problem (part of my job as a green home and lifestyle consultant is to help people ferret it out). I’m not sure legislation could solve this problem though and it may create new ones. We are faced with deceptive marketing practices in so many industries. I tend to believe that marketing is by its nature a dirty business, but that people recognize a company with integrity when they see it.


advertisement

Marketplace

  • gam-logo-long1GreenandMore.com offers green, energy-saving products for a healthy home and office. Contact us about co-branding opportunities and employee discounts for your company.

    More…

  • View more offers

    Quick Vote

    • What do you think will be the biggest green story in 2010 ?

      • The Senate kills cap-and-trade legislation (37%, 146 Votes)
      • Solar and wind energy emerge as affordable ways to cut power bills (30%, 119 Votes)
      • Demand grows sharply for green products and services (17%, 69 Votes)
      • Scientists conclusively settle the global warming debate, one way or another (11%, 43 Votes)
      • Congress approves cap-and-trade legislation (5%, 21 Votes)

      Total Voters: 398

      Loading ... Loading ...

  • advertisement

    See what readers are saying...

    • Blair Thomas: I'm just reacting to what you wrote. Your knowledge may be great. But what you wrote did merit my criticism. I don't w...
    • Blair Thomas: Your religious ferver is admirable, but man, I feel bad for your adherents. So many rules in order to feel righteous....
    • Tom Guay: Blair, don't kill the messenger. Why don't you read all the news links I provided in the story before spouting off li...
    • Blair Thomas: This website is a disgrace. If you knew what you were talking about, you wouldn't say "surprisingly, Lindsey Graham..."...
    • Steve Gilbertson: Obama's moving to the middle because cap and trade is just alot of B.S. and he knows it - they (dems) thought they could...
    • Ryk: My wife expects a real valentine and real chocolates. Enjoy the snow....


    a